Xgau SezThese are questions submitted by readers, and answered by Robert Christgau. New ones will appear in batches every third Tuesday. To ask your own question, please use this form. June 26, 2025Stopping the car for the Beach Boys, choice Leadbelly collections, best of the '80s, Hong Fat and Michael Hurley remembered, and dud vs. neither (Warren Zevon edition). [Q] I've enjoyed your reviews for many years, Robert. As I've aged, I've grown more fond of the early Beach Boys. When you write about the classic bands of the '60s, I've noticed that many of their albums are designated "A Basic Record Library; CG80: Rock Library: Before 1980." But you start your reviews of Beach Boys albums after they peaked mid-decade. Don't a few of their early albums (not Pet Sounds—I read what you said about that) merit that designation, too? At the very least, I think All Summer Long and Today! are classic albums from a lost golden age. -- Daniel Nappo, Martin, Tennessee [A]
Especially in the wake of Brian Wilson's death, it's conceivable that
were I to replay the Beach Boys' by all means likable albums of the
early '60s, I'd admire them more enthusiastically than I did back when
I was just starting out in rock criticism in 1967. But they were
definitely what we called a singles band until the Beatles and the
Stones reset the goalposts, whereupon they upped the ante with Pet
Sounds and the glorious "Good Vibrations," which I can remember
stopping the car for on 10th Street driving home from Brooklyn so I
could concentrate first time I heard it. In my opinion their peak will
always be 1967's
Wild Honey, which at some
point (don't really remember the details) I slotted an A plus. Still
love it, not least because in the summer of 1972 my new girlfriend
Carola, who had never given the Beach Boys a moment's thought, fell
head over heels for it. Hadn't played it in a while when I put it on
at dinner tonight, when "Darlin'" and "I'd Love Just Once to See You"
and the rest sounded as great as ever to both of us. But if you'd like
to explore the band more thoroughly I suggest you find a copy of Beach
Boys fanatic and recent
And It Don't Stop contributor Tom Smucker's
Why the Beach
Boys Matter, which I helped edit.
[Q] In a 2013 interview you named Lead Belly as one of the non-jazz artists you listened to before discovering rock & roll, yet there seems to be scant available writings by you on his work (at least that I can find). Do you still enjoy/ appreciate his music? Are there any specific compilations of his work (CD or vinyl) that you would recommend? -- Rogan Hely, Coffs Harbour, New South Wales, Australia [A]
I own 10 Leadbelly CDs on such labels as Rounder, RCA, Columbia
Legacy, and especially Smithsonian Folkways. The two I'm most likely
to play occasionally are still in jewel boxes (with shelf space at a
premium around here, most are in plastic slipcases): Where Did You
Sleep Last Night and Shout On, both on Smithsonian. I also
reviewed Charles Wolfe and
Kip Lornell's recommended although somewhat partial 1993 The Life
and Legend of Leadbelly for the NYTBR. Let me thank my
first girlfriend, ID'd as Miriam Meyer in Going Into the City
to protect her privacy, for introducing me to both Leadbelly and the
Weavers, crucial figures in my early musical development. She was an
enthusiastic jazz fan as well, but also more of a folkie than I ever
was.
[Q] Hey, I found the link to your favorite albums of the 1980s, and it was disappointingly only a top 10. Considering how you typically have A+'s in your top 10 lists, did you exclude London Calling because you simply prefer those ten albums more or because it was initially released during 1979 in the UK? -- Rolando Simon, State College, Pennsylvania [A]
That list was coughed up, with some checking around I'm sure, for an
end-of-decade special edition of the Voice. If you're that
interested, and I'm flattered that you are, I see where new and used
copies of Christgau's Record Guide: The '80s are available at
Amazon and hopefully less exploitative sellers. The after-matter does
provide A Lists for every year of the '80s; London Calling tops
the 1980 A List. No longer remember my reasoning as to that omission
from my end-of-decade list, but it was, after all, 35 years ago that I
published that book, whose dedication reads "Nina—I'm
done. Wanna go to the park?" My nephew Julian Dibbell, no longer a
rock critic and now a legal partner in Chicago, helped a lot
organizing that book (his early explorations of the digital world
My Tiny Life and
Play Money are still available). Those were the days.
[Q] Hi, Bob, I am a nostalgic person. Even if we are in different places, I always find some resonances with my culture when reading your articles, such as the Hong Fat restaurant on Mott Street that closed many years ago mentioned in your biography, the black bean sauce beef you ate with your grandfather when you were a child, and the winter melon cake you bought in your article. Can you tell us about your story with Hong Fat and these Cantonese restaurants? -- Mike Chan, Guangzhou, China [A]
In the Queens where I grew up in the '50s and '60s the Chinese people
who have long dominated the Main Street area of my native Flushing
were still exotic and Chinese restaurants rare although fairly busy on
Sundays. My beloved grandfather Tom Snyder lived a few miles closer to
Manhattan in Forest Hills, already a relatively Jewish neighborhood,
and in his open minded way explored the culinary offerings of Queens
Boulevard, which is how he came to take me to the place he called "the
Chinese." I have no doubt I ordered what he recommended when he
did. Hong Fat, however, was another story. I was introduced to it by
the great editor Clay Felker, who gave me my start in magazine
journalism, when circa 1967 I gave him a lift in my car from the
downtown offices of what I think was called the World Journal
Tribune to his snazzy 57th Street apartment and he suggested we
stop for a bite in Chinatown, which was then almost entirely south of
Canal Street. That I should a) own a car in NYC (whence I commuted to
Newark so I could work for the Star-Ledger there) and b) be
able to find a place to park it in Chinatown (those streets were short
and narrow) was highly atypical even for the time. But Clay knew his
restaurants and directed me to the now long-gone Cantonese Hong Fat,
63 Mott Street. Hong Fat definitely had a rep as both cheap and good
and I subsequently ate there many times. There are now Chinese
restaurants all over Manhattan, although we're still scrounging around
for a first-rate one in our nabe. But there are few as mythic as Hong
Fat.
[Q] Were you made aware of Michael Hurley's passing? I was a big fan of his work, but did not get to know about his death a month after the fact. -- Nissim, Bombay, India [A]
I was aware of his passing early and was in fact
interviewed about him by a mag connected to my New Hampshire-based
alma mater Dartmouth College. Check him out
on my site, where I make clear
enough that his late work is a lot creakier if still often fun than
the masterful Have Moicy! On the other hand, much of the early
music was pretty damn good.
[Q] Seriously, Warren Zevon's Mr. Bad Example is a dud? It's all cement factory sunshine, beer drinking in the toxic sunshine down on the corner. That's at least an A, man. -- Martin Moeller, Vejle, Denmark [A]
I don't really expect amateurs to fully grok
my grading "system," but
let me make two points. First, much better to say "at least an A
minus," because "at least an A" implies "maybe even an A plus," and A
pluses are too rare to make unlikely claims for. Second, that little
face next to the album you have every right to adore because your
taste is your own, doesn't indicate Dud, it indicates what I like to
call Neither. The little bomb next to Learning to Flinch indicates
Dud. Under these circumstances I feel no obligation to relisten to
these albums unless you get the Warren Zevon Fan Club on the job and
maybe not then either—though I did appreciate your putting the
effort into those somewhat obscure beer and cement metaphors.
|
|