|
|
And It Don't Stop on Substack
Robert Christgau's newsletter And It Don't Stop
appears three (or four) times a month on Substack. Subscribe
here.
Robert Christgau's Big-Hearted Theory of Pop
Book Reports features reviews of not only the pop-music
tomes you'd predict but also literary fiction, Marxist-adjacent
cultural commentary, feminist debates over pornography, and even books
about the past decade's financial crisis. It follows a collection that
Christgau published last year, Is It Still Good to Ya? Fifty Years
of Rock Criticism, 1967-2017, which includes Christgau's takes on,
among many other things, classic rock, Kanye West, the music of Desert
Storm, Lollapalooza, Ladysmith Black Mambazo, and so-called guilty
pleasures--a category that Christgau rejects, since, for rock critics,
as he puts it, "pleasure is where meaning begins." Together, these
collections make the sneaky case that Christgau is not just the Dean
of American Rock Critics, his self-awarded and perhaps slightly
off-putting nickname, but one of America's
sharper public intellectuals of the past half century, and certainly
one of its most influential--not to mention one of the better stylists
in that cohort. Fun is a big part of why.
--David Cantwell, The New Yorker
News
Expert Witness: You'd Think Willie Nelson Wrote the Song About Pot
New in Expert Witness:
- Boz Scaggs: A Fool to Care (429) A-
- Leonard Cohen: Can't Forget: A Souvenir of the Grand Tour (Columbia/Legacy) A-
- Willie Nelson and Merle Haggard: Django and Jimmie (Legacy) ***
- Richard Thompson: Still (Fantasy) **
- Bruce Springsteen: High Hopes (Columbia) *
- Elvin Bishop: Can't Even Do Wrong Right (Alligator) *
[posted by Webmaster on 2015-09-04] Expert Witness: Yo La Tengo Made Their Loveliest Album Ever
New in Expert Witness:
- Yo La Tengo: Stuff Like That There (Matador) A
- Freedy Johnston: Neon Repairman (Singing Magnet) B+
- Rhett Miller: The Traveler (ATO) ***
- Giant Sand: Heartbreak Pass (New West) ***
- Wilco: Star Wars (dBpm) ***
[posted by Webmaster on 2015-08-28] Website Update Status: Working I attempted an update of the website this afternoon (about 3:30 PM CDT).
The flat file part went smoothly, so there are a number of new files and
minor programming changes. See
Changelog for further information (although
I doubt it actually covers everything).
Initially the database failed due to a version incompatibility. I
found a workaround for this, so the database is currently loaded and
functioning. Sorry for the brief inconvenience. Please send mail to
webmaster [@] robertchristgau.com if you find further problems.
[posted by Webmaster on 2015-08-25] Expert Witness: Hopping Along Into a Girlpool
New in Expert Witness:
- Hop Along: Painted Shut (Saddle Creek) A-
- The Go! Team: The Scene Between (Memphis Industries) A-
- Chastity Belt: Time to Go Home (Hardly Arts) **
- Lizzy Mercier Descloux: Press Color (Light in the Attic) **
- Joanna Gruesome: Peanut Butter (Slumberland) **
- Girlpool: Before the World Was Big (Wichita Recordings) **
[posted by Webmaster on 2015-08-21] Expert Witness Returns
New in Expert Witness:
- Sam Smith: In the Lonely Hour (Capitol) A-
- Miguel: Wildheart (RCA) A-
- Jason Derulo: Everything Is 4 (Beluga Heights/Warner Bros.) A-
- Tinashe: Aquarius (RCA) ***
- Oceaán: The Grip EP (Rough Trade) **
[posted by Webmaster on 2015-08-14] Perfect Sound Forever Robert Christgau was guest editor for the
August/September 2015 issue of the online music magazine,
Perfect Sound Forever. In his
introduction,
Christgau wrote:
Like its predecessors
(2008 &
2011),
the third NYU/Tisch Clive Davis Institute of Recorded Music edition of
Perfect Sound Forever is dominated by final papers, mostly by
sophomores, in my required Artists and Audiences history and writing
course. The ringers are papers written for the '50s Rock and Roll
course I taught in the spring, two of them are also by sophomores
(from Steinhardt and Gallatin) and one of them by a ReMu senior. As
before, I think these students have done critical work that deserves
the kind of public presence PSF can provide--writing at least as good
and often better than professional work I've edited.
[posted by webmaster on 2015-08-06] Expert Witness at Cuepoint/Medium It took a while, as new business models cough-cough always do, but
as of June 25 what had seemed increasingly likely ever since my June 5
submission was put on hold became official: 10 months in, Expert
Witness's run at Cuepoint/Medium is over. Editor Jon Shecter
compensated me well and always gave me the freedom he'd promised, for
which I'm very grateful--it felt so right to be reviewing (and
grading) albums after a year's hiatus. But let me emphasize that both
the compensation and the institutional home were part of the
satisfaction--I like earning money for my work and I like being part
of a top-edited periodical.
As with MSN in 2013, I have not been singled out here. Where MSN
offed its entire freelance sector, Shecter's bosses have apparently
decided that their music "vertical" will now feature what web
publishers like to call "reader-provided" copy. Me, I think the term
"unpaid" is more to the point. Having made a living as a journalist
for more than 50 years now, I don't regard writing as a hobby, or as
"self-expression." It's a job, and better for it. Having taken a
teaching post in part because it's hard out there for a freelancer, I
expended most of what little spare time remained between September and
May keeping EW afloat. One sad thing about the timing of the Medium
reboot is that with the spring term over I was going back to stuff I'd
never fully borne down on and seeking out titles I'd missed. It was
interesting--in fact, kind of exciting.
I'm still listening to current music all day and writing occasional
reviews, but with less organizational purpose--often as a way to get
my head around something I've immersed in deep enough. My basic theory
hasn't changed. My working assumption is that popular music is of
lasting artistic value, that the album format remains an excellent way
to realize that value, that an album's potential often becomes more
vivid when it's a physical object, and that my little reviews have
proven of some importance in a complex historicizing process. If
somebody wants to pay me to continue to publish these reviews, I'll
definitely consider it, and it's possible the Witnesses, as I call the
amazingly articulate fan base that crystallized when MSN turned the
Consumer Guide into Expert Witness in 2010, will persuade me to go it
alone in some format yet to be determined, although I have
reservations about every one so far proposed. I can't see any way,
however, that such a development will come to fruition before Carola
and I take a two-week European vacation set to commence three weeks
from today--although I do admittedly have a dozen reviews in the kitty
and may even turn out a few more before we leave.
It's conceivable I'll see you in September--even August. Just in
case, though, I figure I owe the Witnesses at least one small
thing--the final listing in a file called EWMDEX in my WP51 files. It
goes:
6/5 scaggs/cohen//nelson-haggard/giant sand/springsteen/bishop
[posted by Robert Christgau on 2015-06-30] Ornette Coleman Robert Christgau reviewed Ornette Coleman's last live performance
(he believes) for Billboard almost exactly a year ago:
Ornette Coleman in Prospect Park,
June 12, 2014.
[posted by Webmaster on 2015-06-11] Website Charset Errors UPDATE: I believe that the following problem has been fixed.
Please let us know if it hasn't, or if you see other problems. Thanks.
The website was recently migrated to a new server with more recent
software releases of PHP, MySQL, etc. The effect of this change is that
the software now defaults to the UTF-8 character set, instead of the
previous default, ISO-8859-1 (Latin-1), in effect way back when the
website was originally built. All of the text/data in the website is
encoded according to the old standard. However, when the new software
processes the old data, it tends to drop strings when encountering
characters that are encoded differently (mostly characters with accents
used in French, Spanish, German, and other West European languages).
[posted by Webmaster on 2015-06-02]
New in Expert Witness:
- Parkay Quarts: Content Nausea (What's Your Rupture?) A-
- Slutever: Almost Famous (self-released) A-
- Wire: Wire (Pinkflag) ***
- White Lung: Deep Fantasy (Sub Pop) **
- Total Babes: Heydays (Wichita) **
- Spider Bags: Frozen Letter (Merge) **
[posted by Webmaster on 2015-05-29]
New in Expert Witness:
- Tamikrest: Adagh (Glitterbeat '10) B+
- Tamikrest: Toumastin (Glitterbeat '11) A-
- Tamikrest: Chatma (Glitterbeat '13) A-
- Imarhan Timbuktu: Akal Warled (Clermont Music) ***
- Tamikrest: Taksera (Glitterbeat '15) *
Other recommended links:
[posted by Webmaster on 2015-05-22]
New in Expert Witness:
- Cracker: Berkeley to Bakersfield (429) A-
- The Mountain Goats: Beat the Champ (Merge) A-
- Sun Kil Moon: Benji (Caldo Verde) B+
- Modest Mouse: Strangers to Ourselves (Epic) ***
- Clem Snide: Girls Come First (Zahpwee) **
- Mac McCaughan: Non-Believers (Merge) *
Other recommended links:
[posted by Webmaster on 2015-05-15]
New in Expert Witness:
- Young Fathers: Dead (Anticon) A-
- Young Fathers: White Men Are Black Men Too (Big Dada) A-
- White Mandingos: The Ghetto Is Tryna Kill Me (Fat Beats) A-
- Death Grips: The Powers That B (Third Worlds/Harvest) B+
Other recommended links:
[posted by Webmaster on 2015-05-08]
New in Expert Witness:
- Huey "Piano" Smith: Rockin' Pneumonia and the Boogie Woogie Flu (Hallmark) A
- James Booker: Gonzo (RockBeat) A-
- Cracking the Cosimo Code: 60s New Orleans R&B and Soul (Ace) B+
- Huey "Piano" Smith: That'll Get It (Even More of the Best) (Westside) **
Other recommended links:
[posted by Webmaster on 2015-05-01]
New in Expert Witness:
- Sunny Sweeney: Provoked (Thirty Tigers) A-
- Sturgill Simpson: Metamodern Sounds in Country Music (High Top/Thirty Tigers) B+
- Steve Earle & the Dukes: Terraplane (New West) **
- Sturgill Simpson: High Top Mountain (High Top Mountain) **
- Corb Lund: Counterfeit Blues (New West) *
[posted by Webmaster on 2015-04-24]
New in Expert Witness:
- Courtney Barnett: Sometimes I Sit and Think, and Sometimes I Just Sit. (Mom + Pop) A
- Nellie McKay: My Weekly Reader (429) A-
[posted by Webmaster on 2015-04-17]
New in Expert Witness:
- James McMurtry: Complicated Game (Complicated Game) A
- Terry Allen: Bottom of the World (self-released) A-
- Gurf Morlix: Eatin' at Me (Rootball) ***
Recent links for Robert Christgau's Going Into the City:
Recent links for Carola Dibbell's The Only Ones:
[posted by Webmaster on 2015-04-10]
New in Expert Witness:
- Kendrick Lamar: To Pimp a Butterfly (Top Dawg/Aftermath/Interscope) A-
- Rae Sremurrd: Stremm Life (Eardrum/Interscope) A-
- Drake: If You're Reading This It's Too Late (Cash Money) ***
- Far East Movement: K'Town Riot (Cherrytree) **
- J Cole: 2014 Forest Hills Drive (Roc Nation/Columbia) *
Recent links for Robert Christgau's Going Into the City:
Recent links for Carola Dibbell's The Only Ones:
[posted by Webmaster on 2015-04-03]
New in Expert Witness:
- The Paranoid Style: The Power of Our Proven System (Misra cassette '13) A-
- The Paranoid Style: Rock and Roll Just Can't Recall (Worldwide Battle) A
- The Close Readers: The Lines Are Open (Austin) A-
Recent links for Carola Dibbell's The Only Ones:
Also, note that
Nylon Book Club picked The Only Ones as one of "the
two books you need to read this month." The other one was by
Kazuo Ishiguro.
[posted by Webmaster on 2015-03-27]
New in Expert Witness:
- Heems: Eat Pray Thug (Megaforce) A
- Lupe Fiasco: Tetsuo & Youth (Atlantic) A-
- Sisyphus: Sisyphus (Asthmatic Kitty) B+
- DJ Rashad: Double Cup (Hyperdub) ***
- Common: Nobody's Smiling (Def Jam/Artium) **
- Serengeti: Kenny Dennis III (Joyful Noise) *
Excerpts from Robert Christgau's Going Into the City:
Also, a few choice links:
-
Mark Athitakis: Going Into the City (BN Review, Feb. 25, 2015)
-
Jack Dickey: How to Survive 13,000 Album Reviews (Time, Feb. 24, 2015)
-
Joanna Scutts: Going Into the City by Robert Christgau review -- lessons
from the 'dean of rock criticism' (The Guardian, Feb. 20, 2015)
-
Arum Rath: Robert Christgau Reviews His Own Life (NPR, Mar. 1, 2015)
-
Devin McKinney: Guts on the Page: Notes on the Absolute Unity of Robert
Christgau (Critics at Large, Feb. 28, 2015)
[posted by Webmaster on 2015-03-20] Most Recent -- More Recent -- More Ancient
More Information
|